The PJM Grid Crisis: How AI & Data Centers Are Spiking Energy Prices

Podcast Streaming Services

Energy Future: Powering Tomorrow’s Cleaner World

Peter Kelly-Detwiler

Energy Future: Powering Tomorrow's Cleaner World invites listeners on a journey through the dynamic realm of energy transformation and sustainability. Listen to this podcast on:

While the tech world focuses on the latest software updates, a massive, invisible crisis is unfolding in the energy sector. Currently, the PJM Interconnect—the grid operator covering 13 states including Ohio and Virginia—is holding a critical auction to secure power capacity for 2027. While these auctions are usually "arcane" and ignored by the general public, this one is different due to a perfect storm of stagnant supply and exploding demand.

Here is how the AI boom is physically reshaping the energy market.

The Catalyst: The AI Boom

The energy landscape shifted dramatically in November 2022 with the launch of OpenAI’s ChatGPT. This "AI butterfly" effect sparked a massive demand for energy-hungry chips from manufacturers like Nvidia, causing data center loads to soar, particularly in key PJM states like Ohio and Virginia.

Demand forecasts that had been flat for a decade suddenly ramped up, adding 30 gigawatts to the projection. However, PJM’s supply side—the actual power generation—could not keep pace due to "interminable interconnection queues" and a lack of new construction.

The Supply Crunch and Price Shock

Compounding the demand issue was "Winter Storm Elliot" in late 2022. During the storm, nearly 40 gigawatts of gas-fired generation failed to perform, forcing PJM to "derate" (lower the capacity rating of) existing assets.

The economic result was brutal: A supply curve that barely budged met a demand curve shifting rapidly to the right.

Historical Average: Capacity prices averaged roughly $37.68 per megawatt-day over three years.

The Spike: For the 2025/2026 delivery year, prices skyrocketed to $269.92.

The New Normal: Despite a price cap negotiated by Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro to protect consumers, the clearing price for 2026/2027 hit $329.17.

A Broken Market Signal?

In a functional market, high prices signal producers to create more supply—like bakers baking more bread when the price of flour rises. However, electricity generation faces a unique hurdle: time. High prices today cannot instantly conjure new power plants because of complex supply chains and regulatory delays.

Consequently, the "elastic response" of the market is broken. We are seeing massive inflation—data center load alone has added $16.6 billion to costs over the last two auctions—without the necessary corresponding increase in power generation.

What Comes Next?

The situation has become a "political hot potato," with state governors expressing a lack of confidence in PJM’s leadership. While the Department of Energy is attempting to step in with a "one size fits all" approach to interconnection, states are pushing back against federal overreach.

As the current auction concludes, stakeholders are bracing for the results to be released on December 17th. With the pressure from data centers reaching a "boiling point," these results may physically and financially test the grid in unprecedented ways

Peter Kelly-Detwiler