APS Battery Fire Report Finally Released

Deutsche Bank to cut investments in fossil fuels; BoA to disclose GHG impacts of lending practices; Panasonic improving battery tech for TSLA; Australia grid operator lays out new 20 yr plan; big hydrogen network planned for Europe; Arizona battery fire report

1) Deutsche Bank to curtail finance of coal mining by 2025, and limiting financing in the oil and gas sector.


2) BoAmerica joined other US banks committed to disclose impacts of lending/financing on GHGs.


3) Panasonic to increase the density of the battery cells for Tesla by 20% over the 5 years.


4) Australian Energy Market Operator 20-yr plan calls for big upswing in DERs, GWs of utility-scale renewables and storage, and a need for optionality in the face of rapid change.


5) 11 gas transmission system operators from nine EU countries announced the European Hydrogen Backbone Initiative, w/15,000 miles of hydrogen pipelines. Stage 1, by 2030, will see 4,500 miles of pipelines connected.


6) Report on APS battery fire finally came out, highlighting dendritic formation in cells leading to a short that propagated into "thermal runaway." Recommendations address a host of issues.

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Solar+Storage Rocks the Free World

1) CA Utilities: Solo solar not so great, but Solar+Storage rocks the free world;

2) Microsoft update on negative carbon strategy (C-neutral by mid-2020; and C-negative by 2030): started a coalition with 7 big businesses to create a carbon roadmap for other corporations; also investing 1$ billion in innovative technology, issuing an RFP for carbon removal approaches;

3) Renewables king NextEra/FPL looking at $65 million project to create H2 from clipped solar.

4) Morgan Stanley says it can be done with surplus wind as well w/in the next two years,

5) Data giant Switch announced biggest behind-the-meter solar project in the world, w/127 MW solar, 240 MWh of batteries

6) Alliant says it will get to net zero by 2050. It doesn't know it yet, but it will eventually move that goal to 2040, or even closer.

7) NY just released a solicitation for up to 2,500 MW add'l offshore wind and 1,500 MW of land-based renewables.

8) FirstEnergy bribery. A complete cultural rip and replace would seem to be on order for that company.

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Distributed Energy Storage Affirmed by US Court of Appeals

Distributed Energy Storage Affirmed by US Court of Appeals; Solar Net Metering Challenge Rejected by FERC; BlackRock Fires Climate Warning Shots; and Green H2 Competitive by 2030

1) US D.C. Court of Appeals denied a NARUC and APPA petition to halt passage of FERC 841. As a result, on-site storage can participate in wholesale markets. Tension is now likely to arise between those markets and the distribution utilities that don't know when those distributed assets are activated, which could cause problems.

2) The FERC ruled unanimously to reject a petition that would have quashed state net metering rules allowing customers to sell surplus solar into the grid at a retail rate, essentially running the customer meter backwards. FERC used a procedural argument to say no, so this may recur.

3) Investment management firm BlackRock - with its $7 trillion under management - reported last week that it used its shares to vote against 53 companies not making progress in addressing climate change. 37 of the companies it addressed were energy companies with the combined market cap of $408 billion.

4) IHS Markit says green hydrogen from renewables being cost competitive with fossil fuel-derived gray hydrogen by 2030. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Pulling the Plug on the Atlantic Coast Gas Pipeline

Pulling the Plug on a Major Pipeline; New South Wales Going Straight From Coal to Renewables; EU Launches Green H2 Strategy; Saudi Arabia Announces Huge H2 Project

1) Duke Energy & Dominion Energy announced cancellation of Atlantic Coast, a 600-mile planned gas pipeline from West Virginia's Marcellus to Southern North Carolina. Gas is increasingly under pressure.

2) The New South Wales government confirmed it will call for 8,000 megawatts of wind, solar and energy storage, shifting away from coal straight to renewables without a gas bridge.

3) The EU launched its new green hydrogen strategy and may need as much as 80,000 to 120,000 MW of wind and solar resources to power electrolyzers, creating 6,000 megawatts of electrolyzer capacity by 2024, producing up to 1 million tons of H2. The plan calls for major R&D investments, regulatory changes, and development of new markets.

4) Saudi Arabia is charging ahead with H2. Air Products signed with Saudi-based ACWA Power International to develop a $5 billion hydrogen-based ammonia plant powered by renewable energy and capable of producing 1.2 million tons of ammonia annually and 650 tons of hydrogen daily. The H2 party is just getting started.

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Spain Shuts 50% of Remaining Coal Plants

Spain shuts down nearly half its remaining coal plants; Four utilities in three states jump straight from coal to renewables & storage; PGE announces virtual power plant w/storage; Shell writes down $22 bn of assets

1) Spain announced it shut nearly half its remaining coal plants - taking 4,360 MW of capacity offline. Four add'l plants at 3,092 MW have also filed to close.

2) Four utilities in southwestern three states announced plans to move straight from coal plants right to renewables and batteries, without using gas as a bridge fuel.

3) Portland General Electric announced a pilot virtual power plant to connect & direct 525 residential energy storage systems and deliver up to 4 MW of grid services back to the utility. This isn't a new type of a program. Vermont's Green Mountain Power initiated a similar project years ago. It's expanded it with a tariff, enrolling 500 new customers every year.

4) Shell taking a $22 billion haircut, with the asset valuation updates reflecting "Shell's strategy to reshape and focus its refining portfolio to support the decarbonisation of its energy mix leveraging assets and value chains in key markets." My advice for Shell is to keep the write-down pen out. This process is far from over. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Amazon Announces $2Bn for Climate Pledge Fund

Amazon announces climate pledge fund; Electrify America build first charging necklace across U.S.; MA AG asks regulators to review gas consumption/climate goals; DOE eyeing $100 mn for hydrogen research.

1) Amazon is creating a $2 bn pot to invest in sustainable tech to help it meet its goal of transforming to
net zero emissions by 2040. But its own carbon footprint was up 15% last year (oops!). Amazon is also renaming
Seattle's Key Arena to Climate Pledge Arena. It doesn't exactly roll off the tongue...

2) VW's Electrify America finished the first of two
planned cross-country EV fast charging corridors, a 2,700-mile link between L.A. and D.C. along Interstates 15 and 70. w/chargers every 70 miles, up to 350 kW.

3) MA AG is asking the Department of Public
Utilities to look into the future of natural gas in the state. Gas currently meets about two-thirds of space and water heating so state needs strategies around gas to meet legally binding CO2 emissions targets.

4) DOE does something intelligent for a change, announcing intention to invest up to $100 million over 5 years in two National Lab led consortia to advance hydrogen
and fuel cell tech, R&D. Affordable electrolyzers and advanced fuel cells are the focus.

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Bigger Wind Turbines & Taller Towers - Perhaps of Wood or Concrete

Amazing tech stories this week! Taller wind towers (wood and cement); bigger land-based turbines (5.6 MW) coming to U.S.; liquid air batteries getting real; so are solid state; and 8Minute planning on 24 GWh of installations

1) Wooden wind towers - up to 150 meters) may be cheaper than steel says Modvion.

2) GE says not so fast, we plant to print towers with concrete and get to 200 meters.

3) Vestas showing off its monster land-based turbines with an order in TX for 5.6 MW machines.

4) More wind = more need for storage, which is good for HighView, who is building its 1st large liquid air storage facility in the UK, at 50 MW/250 MWh, teamed with a combined cycle gas turbine.

5) 8Minute Energy is going to use a whole heck of a lot of batteries, planning on 24 GWh of storage tied to solar projects.

6) and VW investing another $200 mn in solid state tech and associated manufacturing capability.

Things are about to get very interesting...

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
SPP Notches Three New Wind Records Briefly Hits 73% of Generation Mix

Southwest Power Pool hits record wind; RWE and ThyssenKrupp team up on big green hydrogen project; floating a growing concept in solar; India's Adani wins record 8 GW bid

1) SPP set records in March and April for highest
percentage of wind in resource mix for both a single hour, 72% on 4/27, 1-2:00 AM, and single full-day, 62% on Saturday, 3/7. Last year, wind energy in SPP averaged 29% of total demand.

2) Two of Germany's largest polluters join ranks w/green H2 project. RWE will build a 100-MW H2 plant, from renewables, to supply steelmaker ThyssenKrupp, by 2025. They'll create 1.7 tons of H2 per hour, 70% of needed supply for planned furnace, making 50,000 tons of clean steel, enough for about 50K cars. Steelmaking generates roughly 7-9% of total emissions.

3) floating solar iscoming to the fore, as a potentially big resource. EDF, Equinor, Statkraft and EDP s announced they're working on a technical industry partnership
with consultant DNV GL. DNV estimates that inland man-made waters could host 4 TW of solar power globally,
w/3 GW already installed.

4) India's Adani Green Energy won $6 bn, 8 GW solar contract. (context: US expected to install roughly 24 GW in 2020).

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Swapping EV Batteries & Mandating Chargers at Gas Stations

Chinese EV maker with half a million battery swaps; Germany requiring gas stations to put in EV chargers; Oil companies may lose as much as 2/3 of their value; NY w/massive onshore wind project

1) Chinese automaker NIO claims to have completed 500,000 battery swaps as of the end of May, a little over two years after it started, w/131 stations in 58 Chinese cities. A 3-minute swap is a better customer experience, but it's hard to see how the entire industry will shift to this approach, w/so much already invested.

2) Germany is looking at mandating that all gas stations have to offer EV charging. That could move sales just a bit.

3) London-based think tank Carbon Tracker that says that large hydrocarbon companies are at risk of seeing as much as 2/3 of their value - $25 trillion - wiped off of their books as a consequence of the forthcoming energy transition.

4) Suddenly New York thinks it's Texas. Regulators just approved a $454 million 340-MW wind farm spanning 30,000 acres southeast of Buffalo. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
14 MW Siemens Gamesa Turbine Raises the Bar

Siemens Gamesa (SG) scores 1st 2 contracts for its 14 MW machines; Orsted teams w/ 5 large Danish companies on H2; UL certifies a wireless EV charging technology; negative power prices in the UK

1) SG announced 14 MW turbine & two orders: the 1st for 300 MW off Taiwan & 2nd off Virginia, w/Dominion 2,640 MW project, ready by 2026.

2) Six of Denmark's biggest companies will create big green H2 projects for transportation & heavy industry. Orsted will lead, w/up to 3 GW wind & 1.3 GW electrolyzer by 2030. Shell has similar H2 project in Netherlands w/up to 10 GW offshore wind by 2040.

3) UL just certified Lumen Group's wireless EV inductive charging technology to its 2750 standard. W/ no physical contact betw vehicle and charger, this type of tech is already in Amsterdam, Oslo, & Nottingham.

4) On May 22, average day ahead wholesale price was -£9.92 per MWh, going as low as £52.03 MWh (approx -$64 US). These prices represent a potential challenge, w/a real bifurcation betw low cost renewables & fuel-fired dispatchable resources. It will be difficult to incentivize the addition of new dispatchable resources in the future; a better mkt structure must be developed to deal with this emerging dynamic, in UK, US, and elsewhere. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Kauai's Power Supply Averaging 100% Renewables for 5 Hours Each Day

Denmark to Develop Two Energy Islands; Kauai at Almost 60% Renewables in 2019; BNEF Says We May Have Already Seen Peak Internal Combustion Car Sales; A New and Low-Cost Way to Create H2?

1) Denmark plans to develop two energy islands with wind turbines generating 4 GW by 2030. One artificial structure in the N Sea could host 10 GW of wind, partly used for production of H2.

2) Kauai generated 59% of its electricity from renewables in 2019 w/35% solar, 11% hydropower, 10% biomass. Customer rooftop supplied 1/3 of the solar. Kauai's been averaging 100% renewables for 5 hours daily in 2020.

3) BNEF reports that EV sales will fall 18% this year to 1.7 million. But internal combustion engine sales will fall 23%. More critically, BNEF's analysis, "Suggests that global sales of internal combustion engines peaked in 2017, and will continue their long-term decline after temporary post-crisis recovery."

4) Startup SGH2 claims that w/plasma torches, heating waste to 4,000°C, it can create green H2 for less than grey H2. Its $55 million facility to start construction near LA early 2021 yielding 38,000 tons of hydrogen annually, largely for fueling hydrogen vehicles in California. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
3 European Oil Cos Invest in Carbon Capture Project

1) Equinor, Shell, and Total, working on $700 million carbon capture project off Norway to store 5 mn tons of CO2 in a reservoir 1.7 miles below North Sea. Either CO2 comes out up front, w/renewables, green hydrogen, or on the back.

2) HECO to buy 460 MW of solar power & 3 GWh storage, w/16 projects starting in 2022. HECO's total solar goes to over 50% w/utility 40% carbon free by 2030.

3) Maine's DEP OKs $950 million 145-mile New England Clean Energy Connect transmission project, for 1,200 MW and 9.55 TWh of hydropower from HQ to MA, possibly by the end 2021. Some enviro groups claim it fights climate change, but the crux is: either it creates additionality, that is, new hydro projects, or it doesn't. Based on my analysis for client, I stand firmly in the latter camp: NECEC does nothing to create additionality, simply moving non-firm exports into firm exports for the next couple of decades, while potentially forcing out new local projects.

4) We may see 3 Gigawatt-hour flow battery factory in Saudi Arabia. Site's already been identified, w/construction this year. The issue, is can they get to scale, drive the cost down, and can they compete in mkt dominated by lithium-ion to date. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
The Long-Duration Storage BreakThrough We Have All Been Waiting For

Super-Long Duration Storage Could Alter the Energy Landscape; Residential Solar Companies Driving Efficiencies - Because They Must

1) MN utility Great River Energy piloting a new storage technology from startup Form Energy, w/ 1MW aqueous air battery system said to be able to deliver 150 hours of continuous power. 150 hours of storage could facilitate a far greater penetration of renewable energy into markets. Critical issue is going to be the commercial and competitive one: Can it compete w/li-ion for the lion's share of value in the shorter duration market, while offering unprecedented value in longer duration one?

2) COVID is spurring adaptation & efficiency. Sunrun and SunPower adjusting very quickly, moving into digital sales, custom-designed software, and remote permitting and site inspection. In an extreme case, SunRun had customer signed up in the morning, we got the permit through, and we installed in the afternoon. That's unprecedented speed. 

Peter Kelly-Detwiler
Installed Battery Costs Down 50% in Just Two Years

Battery Costs Down 50% in Two Years; Abu Dhabi Sees Record Low Solar Price; Chinese Company Eyeing 200 MW of Solar to Green Hydrogen; Hydrogen Applied in Steel Rolling

1) BNEF reported battery system LCOEs have declined 50% in past two years, to $150/MWh for 4-hour duration projects. Implies peakers can now be batteries. Battery projects increasing in duration and size: 2015 saw 1.5 hrs of avg duration vs 2.2 hrs in 2020 projects; proj's grew in size from 3 MW to avg 21 MW.

2) Solar's getting cheaper. Abu Dhabi Power saw new record low tariff for solar project, w/winner at $13.50/MWh, (1.35 cents/kWh) beating last yr's record in Portugal of 1.64 cents.

3) As solar gets cheaper, green hydrogen becomes just a little bit more feasible. China's Baofeng Energy Group broke ground on the world's largest solar-powered hydrogen pilot plant, slated to use a 200-Megawatt solar power plant and electrolyzers. Project will cost $198 million and yield 160 million standard cubic meters of H2/annum.

3) A Swedish steel company announced it had replaced LNG as the source of high temperature heat at a steel rolling mill. Using H2 had no effect on the quality of steel. So, one step closer to green H2 in industry. Stay healthy.

NextEra to Install Enough Batteries to Power RI for 4 Hours

1) New York State is pushing its next wind solicitation of 2,500 WM, w/a 9,000-megawatt offshore goal. However, this new solicitation will be delayed at the request of NYSERDA, owing to COVID-19.

2) Coal is getting destroyed by the coronavirus, and analyst Wood Mackenzie indicates coal demand down between 35% and 40% from 2019. Overall electric demand has dropped 5% - 10%, and most expensive resource is always the first baby kicked out of the bed. In this case, it's coal.

3) Solar cell efficiencies have shot higher, w/3 new records set in April. Two at NREL and one in Germany. A NRELs 6-junction solar cell, w/intensified light hit 47.1% efficiency, & in normal lighting conditions, hit 39.2%. 3rd record in Germany, w/perovskite pegging out at 24.16%.

4) NextEra keeps rolling, adhering to 2020 delivery schedules w/o slippage, and adding 1,600 MW of new projects in Q1. Included are 460 MW of batteries. NEE will invest over $1 billion in battery projects in 2021 - would be sufficient to power Rhode Island for a full four hours. So, lucky if you're in Rhode Island... ;-)